This page was archived on 29/09/2008 and is no longer being updated.

Poor are ignored in making aid work

After the devastating floods in Mozambique in 2000, those affected were given land and material to help rebuild their lives [Simon Rawles]
After the devastating floods in Mozambique in 2000, those affected were given land and material to help rebuild their lives [Simon Rawles]

The "scandal of poverty" will only get worse unless poor communities are part of the decision-making process over how to spend aid, according to major development agencies

A joint statement issued by the Caritas Internationalis network (of which CAFOD is a member) and other leading NGOs criticises the Paris Declaration - a plan for improving the effectiveness of aid - claiming it does not reflect the interests of the poor.

René Grotenhuis, president of CIDSE, says that aid is being judged purely by its "quantity and not by what it delivers", and that the Declaration ignores sustainable development.

Authors of development

Rich country governments are behaving shamefully in still tying aid to the promotion of their own economic interests

Gweneth Berge

He says: "Leaving the poor out of aid effectiveness is like leaving people out of architecture."

The statement comes ahead of the Accra High-Level Forum on Aid Effectiveness (2-4 September), which brings together more than 800 representatives of aid donors from around the world.

The meeting will review the Paris Declaration, which was originally signed by 100 ministers, heads of agencies and other senior officials in March 2005.

Rev. Dr. Mvume Dandala, the General Secretary of the All Africa Conference of Churches (AACC), says: "Accra has the potential to improve how we end this scandal of poverty - but only if it helps poor people become the authors of their development.

“About 29,000 children under the age of five die every day, 21 each minute, mainly from preventable causes.

"Six million of the almost 11 million children who die each year could be saved by low-tech cost-effective measures."

Caritas and CIDSE will be officially represented at the meeting by Gweneth Berge, who is calling for an end to conditions being tied to aid.

She says: “Rich country governments are behaving shamefully in still tying aid to the promotion of their own economic interests.

"Our way has been lost if aid benefits the rich when the poor go hungry in greater numbers.

"Local communities must have a greater role in making decisions that ultimately affect their lives the most."

The joint statement was issued by Caritas, the Symposium of Episcopal Conference in Africa and Madagascar (SECAM), the All Africa Conference of Churches (AACC), the International Cooperation for Development and Solidarity (CIDSE), and ACT Development


take action Rss Feed

Give it up! for Lent 2010

Find out more about our special fundraising scheme for Lent 2010, and access our give it up! online resources, packed full of new, easy ways to get involved and raise money

Gordon Brown [The Guardian/Martin Argles]

The job is not done. Act now for climate justice

Please email Prime Minister Gordon Brown today to call for tougher EU emissions cuts. World leaders must act boldly. They’ll only act if they feel the pressure

(Left to right) Richard Cockle, John Corney, Lizzie Cranfield, and Gavin Baxter celebrate together after finishing the Great North Run 2005 [CAFOD]

Get sponsored to support our work

Take part in one of our CAFOD Challenges, or join Team CAFOD for a run. You can have some fun while supporting our life-saving work across the world

Published on 29/08/2008, last updated on 02/09/2008
in this section
DRC: New report questions benefit of AngloGold Ashanti mine project to communities Mining giant BHP Billiton pulls out of disputed Philippine project Aid: Race against time to pass new Bill Win copies of Alma Mater, featuring Pope Benedict XVI Honduras: Evidence of severe water contamination at Goldcorp mine Climate justice: What next after Copenhagen? Mining and jewellery self-certification system falls short Climate deal: World leaders fail to live up to responsibility EU must stand up for poor and refuse to sign a weak deal Climate: Proposal puts millions at risk Climate change: US finance for poorest a great stride forward Climate change: Less than 24 hours to deliver for the poorest Call for tougher action on human rights abuses Gaza: Take action now to end blockade CAFOD response to EU Council announcement on climate finance Half a million voices call for climate justice World Gifts: Girls' award-winning idea raises thousands Climate: UN must stand up for the poor Lebanon: The right to learn Israel: Picking the best deal for workers South Africa: Faith leaders condemn climate "apartheid" The Wave: 50,000 people demand climate justice Two messages for every minute in Copenhagen Why I'm coming to The Wave Electronics industry "shameful" treatment of workers Alice Ahenda: A tribute Urgent warning about email scams Queen's Speech: Vital moves on corruption and aid Unearth Justice: African Bishops condemn corruption Climate change: Leaders do not have the guts to act El Salvador: Murdered Jesuit priests receive highest honour Deadlock on anti-corruption framework must end Climate change: US delays put Copenhagen treaty at risk Climate change: Europe wastes leadership chance Brazil: Evicted families receiving assistance Climate change: Brown says we face "momentous choice" Climate change: Africa speaks with one voice Honduras: "Frank and truthful dialogue" needed The Wave: Huge rally planned for Plymouth Guatemala: Landmark victory for “disappeared” Honduras: Partner faces death threats amid unrest Aid: Brown pledges to hit 0.7% target Guatemala: Concerns over growing food crisis G20 show "drought of political will" Philippines: challenge to stop discrimination G20: Rich countries “fiddling while Rome burns” G20: Rich must offer helping hand UN summit: Climate change is about humanity's future G20: “Yes we can” attitude needed Climate: EU move is "welcome" but only a start Colombia: Reporting news in a hostile place Sri Lanka: Bishops say all must be allowed home Climate change: Commission's communiqué is "immoral" Greenbelt: Hands up for climate justice El Salvador: Festival highlights risks for migrants St Columba’s raises a record-breaking £15,000 Brazil: Police action over evictions "outrageous" Can Christianity show the way? East Timor: Ten years since independence vote Set the prisoners free Peru: Mine protestors case dropped Coalition urges UN to fight corruption Food crisis forcing families apart Climate Doctor’s summer surgery: ‘Denial Ain’t Just a River in Egypt’ Winner of CAFOD film competition announced Brazil: Victory as evicted families rehoused Unearth Justice: BHP Billiton responds Peru: International outcry brings action Honduras: Coup affects the poorest most Root out bribery to protect the poor Conservatives pledge to put people first Climate Justice: Minister calls for people power G8: CAFOD briefing on climate meeting G8: The language of procrastination G8: Small farmers must get more support G8: Significant pledges but commitment needed Pope Benedict XVI’s Encyclical – ‘Caritas in Veritate' On the campaign trail for Climate Justice DFID White Paper: Business as usual? Why Berlusconi should not lead the G8 G8 in Italy must prove its relevance Leading Theologian joins CAFOD 99% Challenge: More than £1m raised Honduras: Our response to the putsch Climate: UK government “brave” for leading way Copenhagen: Ready to join with government Bishops call for G8 to fulfil commitments Boots leaves the Ethical Trading Initiative Peru: Issue is the common good Honduras: Fears of "serious pollution" at mine Budget: Aid growth and carbon budgets welcome Step into the gap DFID: The fight against world poverty New Archbishop is "forward thinker" G20: One rule for rich, another for poor G20: Pope Benedict writes to Gordon Brown Catholics must be the "salt in the wound" Put People First: Don't forget the poor Put People First: March to be peaceful
sign-up for e-news

News, events, jobs, and ways you can support us. Sign up now

Privacy statement