CAFOD is the official Catholic aid agency for England and Wales

This page was archived on 12/02/2009 and is no longer being updated.

Poznan: Global leaders should be ashamed

Bishop Theotonius Gomes of Bangladesh speaks out for climate justice at the UN climate change talks in Poznan, Poland [CAFOD]
Bishop Theotonius Gomes of Bangladesh speaks out for climate justice at the UN climate change talks in Poznan, Poland [CAFOD]

CAFOD congratulates developing countries for leading the way at the UN climate change talks in Poznan - and tells industrialised nations "shame on you" for their stalling tactics

With a weak package announced from Brussels, and with umbrella countries procrastinating on emissions targets decided at Bali one year ago, progress at Poznan looks remote on the final full day of negotiations.

And yet, while the industrialised nations block the path to strong agreement, the developing countries are leading the way with the strength of their proposals and climate change initiatives.

These developing countries are up for negotiating a better and more sustainable future. They are ready and willing. We can get a good deal by Copenhagen 2009

Liz Gallagher, CAFOD

Huge disappointment

Liz Gallagher, CAFOD climate change policy researcher, says: "Shame on you, industrialised nations. The present state of affairs in Poznan and the EU compromise is a huge disappointment.

"The developing countries have come to Poznan in good faith, they have come to negotiate on an issue that will affect them first and worst, and could impact most severely on their aims for rapid growth.

"And yet, as they bring solid and encouraging proposals to the table, they are meeting a brick wall.

"The industrialised nations aren’t even responding to these proposals, they are wrapped up in financial self-interest. It is shameful."

While Russia shirks emissions targets, China has announced a $600bn stimulus package to help its transition to a low carbon economy by promoting economic restructuring and essential green infrastructure.

While Canada attempts to protect its tar sands industry which could cause runaway climate change, Mexico announced this morning that it has set a specific carbon reduction target - one of the first developing countries to do so.

It pledges to halve greenhouse gas emissions by 2050.

As Japan’s delegates try to undermine the scientific recommendations on emissions target ranges, Brazil has set up a $1bn fund to combat deforestation.

When Australia failed to even bring its agreed emissions targets to Poznan, the South Africans set down a concrete proposal on how to make action on climate change measurable and verifiable.

While European countries come to a weak agreement allowing about two-thirds of emissions to be offset abroad, India has committed to ensuring its per capita emissions will not exceed levels recommended by the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD), and has begun the process of setting up centres for the diffusion of climate technology.

Liz Gallagher adds: "These developing countries are up for negotiating a better and more sustainable future. They are ready and willing. We can get a good deal by Copenhagen 2009.

"All that is needed is the political will of the industrialised nations to step up their game."

Moral and spiritual issue

Former US Vice-President Al Gore also helped take the fight to those who are stalling on the issue, by telling the conference that climate change was a "question of right versus wrong".

The environmentalist told a packed audience: "We need to have the moral courage to do what may seem difficult. It is wrong for this generation to destroy the planet for future generations.

"Our children have a right to hold us to a higher standard than the generations before us. This is not a political issue, it is a moral and spiritual issue."

Liz Gallagher welcomed his comments as helping to lift the spirits of those working tirelessly for a socially just and equitable deal.

She says: "Morality seems to be woefully deficient at these talks - we will work with our sister agencies from across the world to ensure that next year, morality and justice are injected into the negotiations.

"Hope and faith will be an essential prerequisite for any deal in Copenhagen."

Media: Contact (Poznan): Pascale Palmer +44 7785 950 585 ppalmer@cafod.org.uk


What the climate justice campaign is calling for

The climate justice campaign calls on governments to negotiate a socially just post-2012 climate agreement including:

  • Recognition and support for the right to sustainable development of people in developing countries
  • Provision by industrialised countries of additional, sufficient and secure funding and technical support to help developing countries adapt to the impacts of climate change
  • Commitment by industrialised countries to at least a 30-40 % cut in greenhouse gas emissions by 2020, based on 1990 levels
Published on 12/12/2008, last updated on 05/01/2009
in this section
CAFOD Media Centre CAFOD response to the G8 Summit meeting in Canada Afghanistan: CAFOD welcomes government aid Niger food crisis Thank you for making poverty an election issue CAFOD calls for aid commitment in Queen's speech Haiti: How the debt was dropped Queen's Speech: Our response on aid CAFOD volunteers – we salute you! UN's Yvo de Boer says A budget that helps the poorest Budget response from CAFOD director Chris Bain - Aid: not goodwill, but a moral imperative CAFOD response to International Development Committee report Bribery Act 2010-04-09 CAFOD calls on mining giant AngloGold Ashanti to share its contract with local community Supporting communities affected by violence in Jos Chile quake response reaches half a million people Religious conflict in Nigeria Climate: Proposal puts millions at risk Chile quake: Caritas aid gets through Warning about email scam Mining giant BHP Billiton pulls out of disputed Philippine project Aid: Race against time to pass new Bill Honduras: Evidence of severe water contamination at Goldcorp mine Climate justice: What next after Copenhagen? Mining and jewellery self-certification system falls short Climate deal: World leaders fail to live up to responsibility EU must stand up for poor and refuse to sign a weak deal Climate change: US finance for poorest a great stride forward Call for tougher action on human rights abuses Climate change: Less than 24 hours to deliver for the poorest CAFOD response to EU Council announcement on climate finance Half a million voices call for climate justice World Gift for Mother's Day Climate: UN must stand up for the poor Lebanon: The right to learn Israel: Picking the best deal for workers South Africa: Faith leaders condemn climate "apartheid" The Wave: 50,000 people demand climate justice Two messages for every minute in Copenhagen Why I'm coming to The Wave Electronics industry "shameful" treatment of workers Alice Ahenda: A tribute Urgent warning about email scams Queen's Speech: Vital moves on corruption and aid Unearth Justice: African Bishops condemn corruption Climate change: Leaders do not have the guts to act El Salvador: Murdered Jesuit priests receive highest honour Climate change: Europe wastes leadership chance Deadlock on anti-corruption framework must end Brazil: Evicted families receiving assistance Climate change: US delays put Copenhagen treaty at risk Climate change: Brown says we face "momentous choice" Guatemala: Landmark victory for “disappeared” The Wave: Huge rally planned for Plymouth Honduras: "Frank and truthful dialogue" needed Climate change: Africa speaks with one voice G20 show "drought of political will" Aid: Brown pledges to hit 0.7% target Philippines: challenge to stop discrimination Guatemala: Concerns over growing food crisis Honduras: Partner faces death threats amid unrest Lent promises G20: Rich countries “fiddling while Rome burns” G20: Rich must offer helping hand UN summit: Climate change is about humanity's future G20: “Yes we can” attitude needed Climate: EU move is "welcome" but only a start Colombia: Reporting news in a hostile place Sri Lanka: Bishops say all must be allowed home Climate change: Commission's communiqué is "immoral" Greenbelt: Hands up for climate justice El Salvador: Festival highlights risks for migrants St Columba’s raises a record-breaking £15,000 Brazil: Police action over evictions "outrageous" East Timor: Ten years since independence vote Set the prisoners free Peru: Mine protestors case dropped Coalition urges UN to fight corruption Food crisis forcing families apart Climate Doctor’s summer surgery: ‘Denial Ain’t Just a River in Egypt’ Winner of CAFOD film competition announced Brazil: Victory as evicted families rehoused Unearth Justice: BHP Billiton responds Peru: International outcry brings action Honduras: Coup affects the poorest most Root out bribery to protect the poor Conservatives pledge to put people first Climate Justice: Minister calls for people power G8: CAFOD briefing on climate meeting G8: The language of procrastination G8: Small farmers must get more support G8: Significant pledges but commitment needed Pope Benedict XVI’s Encyclical – ‘Caritas in Veritate' On the campaign trail for Climate Justice DFID White Paper: Business as usual? Why Berlusconi should not lead the G8 G8 in Italy must prove its relevance Leading Theologian joins CAFOD
sign-up for e-news

News, events, jobs, and ways you can support us. Sign up now

Privacy statement
see also
Climate change noticeboard

Have your say on our Climate Justice campaign - or any issue relating to climate change. Whether it is something you want to know, or just share with fellow campaigners, this is the place to find answers